Subaru Impreza (2014) - $9,500

The WRX or STI version of the Impreza from the early 2010s ranks among the best-handling and most powerful cars in this price range. They are also highly reliable and you can depend on them for their authentic Japanese style.

However, if you opt for the base 2.0-liter variant, the engine will leave you wanting more power when you want to overtake on the highway. Nevertheless, these models will cost you less than the WRX and STI versions , so it's up to you whether you want to save a few thousand dollars for more power.

Subaru Forester (2012) - $9,800

The Forester is the only true off-road SUV on this list, offered for under $10,000, that isn't from a prehistoric era. With a powerful engine, capable of maintaining an AWD system , excellent visibility, and superb handling even in adverse conditions, the Forester leaves little to be desired at this price.

In addition to all this, they are built to last. The only drawback is that their interiors don't feature the most suitable materials, as the focus is on durability and longevity, rather than comfort and luxury.